Skip to main content

MAC Rodarte Controversy

While going through a few of my favourite blogs, I chanced upon this huge MAC - Rodarte Controversy that is splitting the blogosphere into two.

MAC apparently is launching a make-up collection abroad, inspired by Mexico, that has some some offensive names and connotations.

For example, one of the nail paints in this line is Juarez.

Juarez is the world's most dangeous and violent town. Everyday, a number of women are abducted on their way to work at factories and brutally raped and murdered. The police is a silent spectator to this atrocity that has been happening for more than 10 years now. The citizens of this town live in abject poverty and fear.

The other products in this range has equally odd names like Factory, Badlands, Sleepless, Ghost Town that are offensive to Latin people and those in Mexico who have been living in very bad conditions for years.

MAC of course has responded quickly and apologised. They have also agreed to donate a portion of the profits to a charity in Juarez. But a lot of bloggers say this is not enough - MAC needs to either withdraw the collection or change the names.

Branding and names in the Make-up industry have gotten very weird over the last few years. NARS is infamous for products like Deep Throat et al. I understand that this maybe helps get attention to the product.

But let's not trivilize someone's misery to name & brand a line. MAC with all it's experts, I am sure could have come up with better names, and I think they should. Let's not use human suffering to peddle makeup.

You can read more about this controversy here and  here

What do you think?

Update (21st September 2010): A lot of you may by now be aware, the line has been withdrawn. MAC has unconditionally aplogised and is commited to donating all of the projected profits from the sale of this line.

Was MAC really innocent? Did we as bloggers read too much into the ad? Should an advertiser take responsibility for every petty little element, most especially when the details hint at charges as serious as rape? Can one read too much into an ad?

The average commercial costs half a million dollars to produce and air. In the production phase, thousands of photographs are taken and miles of video are shot. These images are judged, rejected, resized, electronically manipulated, and finally rendered as a finished advertisement. The ads are often relayed back and forth between the ad team, agency executives, the sponsor’s marketing division, and their upper-level management. Companies spend over $200 billion a year on campaigns designed by advertising professionals in the hope that they will capture a sizable piece of the trillion-dollar global market. When the stakes are that high and the process so expensive and laborious, there is no question that every element is indeed intentional.

MAC knew exactly what it was peddling, it was only thanks to beauty bloggers who challenged MAC that this collection was withdrawn.

Comments

  1. Wowww...put it that way, it sounds so offensive. However, I never knew about this place or the horrible living conditions there, and to look at a positive side of it, at least there is more awareness now. Hopefully, the awareness translates to some action?!! As for a portion of the proceeds, it should have been a voluntary first-step on part of MAC, not as a response to all the controversy. And "a portion" is how much? That apart, I think people there need help, not money!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I never knew about this but at least this way I came to know about this place and horrible living condition of women there..

    ReplyDelete
  3. @Rads: I agree, the positive side is that more people are aware of the horrible situation there. I hope this awareness translates further into some positive action too..

    MAC, well, what do I say.. I am sure naming this collection was not a spur of the moment decision.

    Wikipedia says about Juarez - "the most violent zone in the world outside of declared war zones"..

    I just found that one of the other prdts in this line is called Sleepwalker - a side reference to these women labourers in these factories, they most work night shifts - that is when they are abducted.

    To still go ahead with these names is just being insensitive.

    @Anamika: Yea, it has raised awareness.

    ReplyDelete
  4. this is just out of line...completely insensitive and in very bad taste.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Very insensitive indeed..I am firmly on the anti-MAC side of the debate with this one!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Tanveer, I just went through one of the links you had posted. That eyeshadow, the mineralized one, it was horrible. Just wanted to thank you for posting about this, most times we choose to overlook the bad in many products thinking its okay, but this time I think they just crossed too much past the line.

    ReplyDelete
  7. @Rads: I know. I don't know what got into MAC. The eyeshadow looks so horrible - like a raw bruise.

    If MAC was looking for publicity - after all even bad publicity is publicity - it certainly got that. But it has totally lost my respect.

    How can you trivalise the fact that around 5000 women have gone missing in this area in the last few years. I shudder at the thought & callousness of MAC. Death & Rape is suddenly Glam for MAC:)

    ReplyDelete
  8. I read bout this in temptalia..but i couldnt figure it out what this was about!! i was soo confused until now..thanks forvlearing that up..and i agree with..MAC has so many experts in PR and everything and they should not take up on people's suffering to sell makeup...
    It seems rather pathetic actually....

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hey Tanveer. This is really unfortunate but sadly this is how companies act. They think giving provocative names means more sales. I have to wonder how successful the orgasm blush would have been without its attention grabbing name. Sad but true. I think MAC should change the names.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Gosh!!! I had goose bumps when I read the post on one of the links u posted....It is really disgusting on the part of MAC to exploit such a condition....I think it would be sensible on their part to withdraw the names...They have already got the publicity they probably wanted...gonna do some googling on juarez

    HD

    ReplyDelete
  11. hi Tanveer This is really unfortunate but i think..its all about for publicity...

    ReplyDelete
  12. I am absolutely appalled. I don't think I can afford MAC anyway, but if I could I would have boycotted the collection and MAC themselves until they offered an unconditional apology.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I think all sensitive and sane people should join their voices in protesting against the horrible insensitivity of Mac.They should realize that they make their products for women and women are their main patronisers and so they cannot under any circumstances trivialize the plight of women or hurt their sentiments to sell their cosmetics.I think no sensitive women can even think of touching, forget buying this range of cosmetics from Mac if they even for a moment think of the extreme plight of women in Juarez.This is downright atrocious and outrageous.I wrote this comment only to voice my protest.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Thank you all for your support and for commenting and voicing your protest.

    The good news is that MAC has finally agreed to change the names on these products.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Tanveer, I felt so strongly that I should find out about this unfortunate black mark in history through MAC .....one other thing they made these poor women do is show the bosses their soiled sanitary napkins every month to prove that they are not pregnant! How revolting as well as an affront to a woman's privacy!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Hey! Thank you for taking the time out to add your valuable comment. I will revert as soon as possible.

COMMENT MODERATION POLICY FOR ADDICTED TO BLUSH BLOG

I delete blatant self-promotion and comments where it is clear the post material was not carefully read. If you are not going to bother to engage with the post, I am not going to bother posting your comment.

I also delete ALL comments with links - even if the link is to your blog.

Don't be mean to other commentators - it serves no purpose other than showcase your own personality in a bad light.

Popular posts from this blog

Skin Care Myth: Sunscreen will stop you from Tanning

Image via Wikipedia I know I did a recent article on skin care myths (read it here), but I don't know how I forgot to mention this particular myth. In any case I think this warranted a post on its own.

Myth: If I use a suncreen regularly and religiously, I will not tan. 

Fact: This is a very simplistic statement. But before I bust this myth, kindly bear through a science lecture. This is to bring all readers of all backgrounds on the same knowledge level.



Lets define sunscreen (from Wikipedia):Sunscreen (also commonly known as sunblock or sun cream) is a lotion, spray, gel or other topical product that absorbs or reflects "some" of the sun's ultraviolet (UV) radiation on the skin exposed to sunlight and thus helps protect against sunburn. Sunscreen helps protect only against direct DNA damage as it cannot dissipate UV as harmless heat.

The SPF of a sunscreen is a laboratory measure of the effectiveness of sunscreen — the higher the SPF, the more protection a sunscreen …

Reetha, Amla & Shikakai Home Made Shampoo - Weekend Experiment

Good Morning Lovelies, I hope your weekend was fun. Mines was, well, ho-hum, but anyways, we are not talking about that here (let’s save that cribbing for twitter).
I have been suffering from quite a bit of hair fall since some time. I have tried changing products to using intensive conditioning and the works. It stops the hair fall for while, but then it rears its ugly head again.
So on lark, & for lack of better things to do, my best friend & I decided to make some Reetha – Amla – Shikakai shampoo at home. This century old ayurvedic herbal concoction is reputed to not only strengthen hair, but also darken it and stop hair fall.
I got the 3 biggies from a local kirana store. All 3 are priced at 15 Rs for 100gms.

How to: Soak 5 pieces of Shikakai, 4 balls of Reetha  (Soapnut) & handful of Amla (Indian Gooseberry)  in about 500 ml of water overnight. In the morning, heat the mixture on gas till it just starts to boil. Let it cool, when lukewarm mash all the amla, reetha and…

The Body Shop Moisture White Shiso Collection - Review

The Body Shop India is about to launch in July, its new line in skincare called MoistureWhite Collection. 

This line consists of products for women who want fairer, clear-looking skin and uniform skin tone with translucent complexion. The collection has a series of products from start to end to take care of your entire regime.

The key ingredients featured in The Body Shop Moisture White Shiso Collection are:
Shiso Extract -- reduces melanin making signals (this plant is also known as Japanese Basil)Vitamin C -- provides antioxidant protection to reduce melanin productionLicorice Extract -- helps address hyperpigmentationCommunity Trade Organic Aloe - to moisturise and hydrate skinBatyl Alcohol - which helps to reduce skins response to the melanin attack on the skin
Below are quick reviews on each of the products in this line, followed by my overall impressions of the collection. I have been using this collection for exactly 2 weeks now.

1. Moisture White Shiso Cleansing Powder (Day): R…